Blue Ribbon Commission on Higher Education
Is Curriculum Related to Quality?
December 10,1998
Remarks of
Dr. Patricia Cromier
President Longwood College
Note to the Reader: These remarks have been provided to the Educational Policy Institute of Virginia
Tech (EPI) by the author. EPI wishes to express its appreciation to Dr. Cromier for her assistance.
Since its inception in the High Middle Ages, the western
university has been the one societal institution that provides
certification of intellectual and educational quality. Possessing
a college or university degree is a universally recognized indicator
that the holder has undergone a stringent, in-depth, high-quality
educational process, a process that was devised and overseen by
a group of experts who possess the highest levels of expertise.
That educational process, the means by which we determine who
has the right to hold society's only official certification of
intellectual quality, is the curriculum. As such the curriculum
is the #1 indicator of quality in our educational institutions.
General Education: The Core of Common Learning
- At the center of any effective curriculum there should
be what Ernest Boyer, an internationally renowned educator, called
"a core of common learning" wherein students are exposed
to the basic elements of our cultural and educational tradition,
and are encouraged to make connections between ideas, concepts
and bodies of knowledge. As Ernest Boyer wrote:
"General education should be the study of those experiences,
relationships, and ethical concerns that are common to all of us
simply by virtue of our membership in the human family at a
particular moment in history."
- The core of common learning must stress not only the acquisition
of knowledge and exploration of ideas, it also must be deeply
committed to the development of the skills, abilities and attitudes
that will enable the graduate to function effectively in the real
world he or she must live and work in.
- The core of common learning must be integrated, coherent,
well-organized and based on measurable learning outcomes.
- Example: Five of the 10 General Education Goals at Longwood
College -
- Goal 1: The ability to write and speak logically, clearly,
precisely, and the ability through accurate reading and listening,
to acquire, organize, present and document information and ideas.
- Goal 4: An understanding of mathematical thought and
the ability to conceptualize and apply mathematical logic to problem
solving; the ability to use computers for acquiring, processing
and analyzing information.
- Goal 5: The application of the methods of science to
the acquisition of knowledge and an appreciation of the major
contributions of science to our cultural heritage and to the solution
of contemporary problems.
- Goal 6: An understanding of the foundations and history
of western civilization, and of the past as a mode for understanding
the present.
- Goal 10: The ability to make informed, ethical choices
and decisions, and to weigh the consequences of those choices.
The Effective Curriculum
- It must be understood that curriculum is not limited
to the classroom and spans the entire living and learning experience
of the college student; the curriculum must be viewed as an all-encompassing
human growth and development experience.
- Example: In a residential environment like Longwood, we
pay close attention to linking classroom instruction to life in
the residence halls to volunteer activities in the community.
- An effective curriculum must connect students with our
cultural past while at the same manifesting a relevancy and timeliness
that will permit the graduate to apply his or her learning in
a manner that will allow them to live productive, secure and beneficial
lives.
- Example: The recently completed Strategic Plan of Longwood
College calls for all of our students to have an internship experience.
We believe every academic discipline has a practical worth and
can provide students with skill sets that are directly applicable
to the world of work. Through internships we require that our
students apply their disciplinary knowledge in a real life work
environment.
- Indeed, the greatest responsibility and the greatest
challenge of the curriculum is to transmit to our students the
knowledge and values accumulated over thousands of years of human
existence, while at the same time creating the opportunity for
that knowledge to be actively applied to the real life conditions
of the modern world.
- An effective curriculum must be flexible and responsive
to the needs of its constituents. With the extremely rapid rate
of change that characterizes our world today, we must have the
processes and mechanisms in place that will allow us to react
rapidly and offer a product that meets the needs of all our constituents
- students, employers, parents, etc.
- The highly diverse nature of the population we serve
- i.e., age, culture, language, economic background, social background
etc. - mandates against a one size fits all solution to curriculum
development. Each of Virginia's institutions has a unique mission
and serves a unique population. It is the responsibility of the
institution to develop a unique curriculum that meets the needs
of its constituents and it is the responsibility of the state
to recognize the benefit to be derived through the institution
doing so.
- Example: there are over 200 languages spoken in Northern
Virginia, with no less than 65 being spoken in one high school
alone. When you combine this with the fact that each of these
languages indicates the unique cultural, historical and sociological
background of the speaker, the implications for educators are
clear: they must have the flexibility to design and develop curricula
that are suited to their unique circumstances.
The College of Character
- One very important aspect of the curriculum has to do
with the civic and ethical development of our students. We cannot
forget or ignore our responsibility to transmit our society's
core values; it is not enough to merely transmit facts and to
teach skills that can lead to gainful employment - we must combine
them with a transcending emphasis on right conduct, personal responsibility
and civic duty.
- Example:The Longwood College Mission Statement (1st Sentence)-
Longwood College is an institution of higher learning dedicated
to the development of citizen leaders who are prepared to make
positive contributions to the common good of society.
The Longwood College Honor Code (in effect since 1910) forbids
lying, cheating, stealing and plagiarism, and "represents
the standards of integrity and moral responsibility that all students
are expected to exemplify in their lives."
The Blue Ribbon Commission and the Curriculum
- Perhaps the most important thing I can say to this group
today has to do with the BRC's involvement in curricular matters:
when examining curricular issues, the BRC should not focus on
defining the processes that will lead to curricular quality -
we should instead define the end product
- Through the By-laws of every institution in the Commonwealth
we empower our faculty to develop and recommend the curriculum
to their Boards of Visitors. The faculty are our curricular experts,
those whom we pay to make sure our institutions offer the best
possible educational programs. This is, in effect, a bottom up
process.
- The most beneficial contribution the BRC can make is
to work with the public institutions to define the core performance
measures that should characterize an educational institution in
the Commonwealth of Virginia - i.e. the end product. The design
of that curriculum is left to our experts, the faculty, who recommend
their programs to Boards of Visitors for approval.
- The performance measures must reflect the uniqueness
of Virginia's individual institutions and should be the result
of a collaboration between individual institutions and the state.
- It is indisputable that Virginia has one of the finest
systems of public education in the world. In the final analysis,
the Commonwealth's greatest educational strength lies in the diversity
of its institutions and the diversity of their curricula. All
of us who are involved in the educational enterprise must now
join together and find the means to ensure that we will continue
to offer a relevant and high quality education well into the next
millennium. The citizens of the Commonwealth deserve nothing less.
Back to the Main Page
EPI would like to thank Dr. Cromier for
allowing us to post her remarks on this web site.
Posted: December 14, 1998
By The
Educational Policy Institute of Virginia Tech
sjanosik@vt.edu